← All Articles

Generally, Women Outperform Men. So Why Are Men More Likely to Get Promoted?

Research reveals how women's reluctance to self-promote, the need to belong, and workplace bias combine to limit advancement—and what needs to change.

Morning sunlight through a large oak beside misty water.

You've worked hard, delivered great results, and earned the respect of your colleagues. Yet when a leadership opportunity arises, too often a male colleague is promoted ahead of you.

He may not have performed as well. But he's been talking confidently about his accomplishments, making his ambitions known, and presenting himself as ready for greater responsibility. Meanwhile, you've been focused on doing excellent work, trusting that your contributions will speak for themselves.

Not likely.

Research supports the idea that this scenario is more than an unfortunate possibility. It reflects two troubling patterns: women can outperform men and still be judged as having less leadership potential, and women themselves tend to describe their achievements less favorably than men who perform equally.

Women Perform Better. Men Get Promoted.

Researchers Alan Benson, Danielle Li, and Kelly Shue examined nearly 30,000 management- track employees at a large retail company. Women received higher performance ratings than men but substantially lower ratings for leadership potential.

Those potential ratings strongly influenced who received promotions. In fact, differences in potential ratings accounted for approximately half the gender gap in advancement.

Perhaps managers were correctly identifying men who would become better leaders? The researchers examined that possibility by looking at employees' subsequent performance, including people whose ratings placed them close to the cutoff for promotion.

They found that women continued to perform better than men. The men's higher potential ratings did not translate into better subsequent performance. Managers had been giving men more credit for future leadership ability than their results justified.

The researchers identified stereotyping and managers' reluctance to lose strong employees from their current positions as contributing factors. Women were doing better work, but men were being credited with greater potential—and that advantage helped men get promoted.

These findings describe group averages in a particular workplace, not universal differences between women and men. Many women are comfortable promoting themselves, and many men struggle with it. Social backlash, learned expectations, personal priorities, and organizational structures may all contribute to broader gender differences in advancement, but their relative importance remains uncertain.

It's also important to distinguish between self-promotion, seeking advancement, and wanting leadership. Someone may want greater responsibility but dislike talking about her achievements. Someone else may advocate confidently for fair compensation without wanting a leadership position.

Women Undersell Their Achievements—Even When They Know They've Done Well

Economists Christine Exley and Judd Kessler examined how women and men described their performance on a math-and-science test. Women performed slightly better than men, yet rated their own performance at approximately 45 out of 100, compared with 61 for men.

Perhaps women simply lacked confidence or didn't know how well they'd performed? The researchers tested those explanations.

The gender gap persisted even after participants learned their actual scores and how they compared with others.It also remained when self-evaluations wouldn't be shared with employers, when there was no financial incentive to promote themselves, and when participants were told how other people typically evaluated their own performance.

Also, when participants evaluated other people's performance, the gender gap disappeared. Women were not less capable of recognizing good performance. The difference emerged when they were asked to describe themselves.

Researchers also found evidence of this gender difference among sixth graders on a male- stereotyped task.

The problem wasn't a lack of confidence or an inability to judge their performance accurately. Something about evaluating and promoting oneself was different.

What might explain this?

What If Success Negatively Impacted Your Sense of Belonging?

Consider a woman who has just received an important professional award. She's delighted and proud of what she's accomplished. But when colleagues congratulate her, she quickly redirects the attention: "It was really a team effort," or "I was lucky."

Perhaps both statements are true. But why is it uncomfortable to simply say, "Thank you. I'm proud of what I accomplished"?

For some women, the discomfort may have less to do with doubting their abilities than with worrying about how others will feel. Will someone feel diminished by my success? Will colleagues think I believe I'm better than they are? Will I appear arrogant? Will people still like me?

These concerns may operate largely outside conscious awareness. A woman may simply experience embarrassment, anxiety, or an urge to redirect attention when her accomplishments are acknowledged.

Often, the conflict isn't between confidence and insecurity. It's between wanting recognition and wanting to belong.

Many girls are "encouraged" to be nurturers: maintaining relationships, being thoughtful, and avoiding conflict. Thus, the focus is on collaborating, building trust, and caring for others.

But these expectations can reinforce the notion that sharing one's accomplishments means elevating oneself above someone else. Ironically, a woman often doesn't hesitate to celebrate a colleague's success but feels uncomfortable celebrating her own.

Research on gender expectations and self-silencing helps explain how women may learn to protect relationships by minimizing their own needs or accomplishments. Exley and Kessler established the self-promotion gap, while this separate body of research offers insight into why promoting oneself may feel uncomfortable.

Research Also Points to Fear of Backlash

Women's concerns about the social consequences of self-promotion are supported by research.

In three experiments, psychologist Laurie Rudman examined how people responded to women and men who promoted their accomplishments. Self-promotion increased perceptions of women's competence but also carried social costs, including reduced likability and, under some conditions, lower ratings of suitability for hiring.

A later meta-analysis by Melissa Williams and Larissa Tiedens examined research on how people respond to "overtly assertive" behavior, such as forcefully asserting authority, directing others, or taking charge in ways that establish dominance.

Across the studies analyzed, women experienced greater social penalties than men for these behaviors. They were more likely to be judged negatively in interpersonal evaluations and hiring decisions, even when their competence was not questioned.

Research by Corinne Moss-Racusin and Rudman examined what happens when women anticipate these consequences. In experiments involving interviews and written self-promotion,

fear of backlash interfered with women's ability to promote themselves successfully. The same process was not found among men promoting themselves or women promoting someone else.

Together, these findings support a troubling conclusion: women may be recognized as competent while being penalized socially for communicating that competence or asserting their authority.

This creates a double bind. Speak confidently about your achievements and risk negative perceptions and, consequently, less inclusion. Remain modest and risk being overlooked for recognition, compensation, and promotion.

Repeated experiences of criticism, disapproval, or anticipated rejection can teach women to minimize their achievements before they consciously consider doing so. From a psychological perspective, that response can become a familiar way of protecting relationships and preserving acceptance.

Why Is It Easier to Advocate for Someone Else?

Research on negotiation reveals another important finding: women can be more assertive when negotiating for someone else than when negotiating for themselves.

A woman might confidently tell her supervisor that a colleague deserves a raise, describe her accomplishments, and make a compelling case for advancement. Yet when asking for her own raise, she may hesitate, soften her request, or worry about appearing demanding.

For some women, advocating for others feels generous and appropriate, while advocating for themselves can feel selfish or uncomfortable. Research also shows that assertive women negotiating for themselves can face negative social judgments.

Generally, women possess the skills they need but feel less socially safe touting their own accomplishments, skills, or ambitions.

The Hidden Cost of Being Helpful

Women can also lose ground by taking on work that benefits their organizations but does little to advance their own careers.

Research by Linda Babcock and colleagues has examined how women disproportionately volunteer for, are asked to perform, and agree to tasks that carry little weight in promotion decisions.

These non-promotable tasks include organizing workplace events, taking meeting notes, coordinating activities, and performing other necessary but less career-enhancing work.

Women may feel greater pressure to be helpful and cooperative or anticipate negative reactions if they refuse. The result can be a costly imbalance: a woman becomes indispensable to her team while having less time for the projects that lead to advancement.

Being valued for helping everyone else succeed isn't the same as being rewarded for your own professional accomplishments and growth.

Women May Be Over-mentored and Under-sponsored

Another striking finding comes from research reported by Herminia Ibarra, Nancy Carter, and Christine Silva in Harvard Business Review.

A Catalyst study followed more than 4,000 high-potential MBA graduates. Women had more mentors than men, yet men received 15% more promotions during the follow-up period.

The women were also paid less in their first post-MBA jobs and occupied lower-level management positions, even after accounting for several relevant career and personal factors.

Why weren't women's mentoring relationships producing comparable advancement?

The researchers identified a crucial distinction: mentors provide advice; sponsors use their influence to secure opportunities and promotions.

Women were receiving considerable guidance and professional development, but men were more likely to benefit from the influential advocacy that opens doors.

The research also found that men were more likely to receive promotions following lateral assignments, while women were sometimes offered additional lateral moves instead of advancement.

This challenges another common response to women's underrepresentation in leadership: telling women they need more mentoring, training, or experience.

So they don't need more preparation. They need someone with influence to recognize that they're ready and advocate for them.

When Ambition Comes With a Cost

Research by Francesca Gino and colleagues also challenges the assumption that women who pursue leadership less aggressively simply lack ambition.

In their studies, women sometimes viewed high-level positions as less desirable than men did, despite seeing those positions as similarly attainable.

Leadership can bring influence, achievement, and financial rewards, but it can also involve conflict, greater demands, reduced flexibility, and pressure on relationships or personal priorities.

Some women may reasonably decide that the costs outweigh the benefits. The question is whether those choices reflect genuine preferences or whether unequal expectations, workplace conditions, and demands at home make leadership too costly.

Not every woman wants a promotion. But those who do shouldn't face greater obstacles to obtaining it.

Not All Women Face the Same Barriers

An important limitation of much of this research is that women are often studied as a single group.

The experiences of cisgender white women cannot automatically be generalized to women of color or transgender women.

It's well known that racialized stereotypes and gender-based discrimination also affect whose authority is respected, whose assertiveness is criticized, and whose achievements are recognized.

Researchers and organizations need to examine these differences rather than assume all women experience the same obstacles, or the same degree.

Organizations Must Stop Rewarding Potential in Men and Demanding More Proof From Women

The research makes one thing clear: telling women to promote themselves more aggressively is not an adequate solution.

Employers must also examine how they recognize accomplishments, assess potential, assign work, provide sponsorship, and award promotions.

They need to address organizational practices that credit men with greater leadership potential than women who have stronger performance records. Promotion and leadership decisions should be based on transparent criteria rather than subjective impressions.

Organizations also need to correct practices that assign women more work that benefits the organization without advancing their careers. They must ensure talented women receive sponsorship from senior leaders who actively recommend them for opportunities and that women who advocate for themselves are evaluated as favorably as men.

This requires fair distribution of career-enhancing assignments, meaningful sponsorship, and accountability for equitable advancement.

Women shouldn't have to outperform men to be considered equally promotable.

What Happens When Organizations Make Self-Promotion Safer?

There is encouraging evidence that changing the culture can influence women's willingness to promote themselves.

In a 2025 experiment, women were substantially less likely than men to promote their own prosocial accomplishments. But when participants received an explicit justification for self- promotion, the gender difference disappeared.

Making self-promotion socially encouraged changed women's behavior in that experimental setting.

One initiative addressing this issue is #IAmRemarkable, originally developed at Google. The program encourages women and other underrepresented groups to recognize their achievements and practice describing them aloud.

Imagine a workplace where managers regularly invite everyone to discuss their accomplishments, acknowledge contributions, and encourage employees to pursue opportunities consistent with their abilities, and where actual performance matters most.

Where talking about your achievements is considered professional rather than boastful, and where women don't have to worry that claiming credit will damage their relationships.

While this can help women feel more comfortable advocating for themselves, it must be backed by meaningful changes in how organizations evaluate and promote employees.

Women Can Change, Too—Without Becoming Someone They're Not

While organizations bear responsibility for creating equitable workplaces, women can also benefit from examining their relationship with recognition, ambition, and self-advocacy.

For some, the difficulty may involve familiar beliefs: "If I draw attention to myself, others will feel diminished." "I shouldn't make anyone uncomfortable." "My work should speak for itself." "I need to prove myself before I ask for more."

These beliefs may have developed through social expectations, earlier relationships, or repeated experiences of criticism and exclusion. They may once have helped a woman maintain acceptance and belonging.

Change may involve becoming more comfortable with feelings that arise when they speak up— embarrassment, guilt, anxiety, or fear of criticism.

Psychotherapy, including somatic and relational approaches, may help women explore these patterns and develop greater freedom to respond more confidently.

We'll explore these psychological possibilities more deeply in a companion article.

Both Women and Workplaces Have Work to Do

Women can learn to trust themselves to express their accomplishments and ambitions, set boundaries, and advocate for themselves without paying a social price. Organizations must create environments where those efforts are welcomed, achievements are fairly recognized, and promotions reflect ability rather than gendered expectations.

Women should not have to work harder, prove more, or become better self-promoters than men to receive the same opportunities. And they shouldn't have to choose between professional success and a sense of belonging.

Joanne Davis, LMFT, is a California psychotherapist with more than 20 years of experience helping adults understand and change longstanding patterns that affect their relationships, work, and well-being.

Back to top