You've worked hard, developed considerable expertise, and earned the respect of your colleagues. You're proud of yourself for the important project you just completed and hope it will lead to a promotion.
You have no problem describing your contributions in a written report to management. But around the water cooler, you say very little. When a colleague asks how the project went, you find yourself saying, "It went pretty well. Everyone worked really hard."
Later, your VP compliments you on the outcome. You thank her and share that it was a group effort—even though the project was largely your work.
There's nothing wrong with appreciating your colleagues.
While you're busy at your desk getting your work done, you've likely noticed male colleagues out on the floor, comfortably discussing their accomplishments with coworkers and management.
How is it that you feel proud of your accomplishments yet hold back from sharing that pride, while men generally seem more comfortable expressing theirs?
Women Are Less Likely to Promote Their Accomplishments. Why?
Research by economists Christine Exley and Judd Kessler found that women rated their performance substantially lower than men did, even when their actual performance was comparable or better.
The difference persisted after participants learned their actual scores and how they compared with others. Yet when women evaluated someone else's performance, the gender difference disappeared.
Women could recognize good performance. The difference came when they were asked to describe their own.
These findings describe group averages, not every woman or man. Evaluating test performance also isn't identical to discussing accomplishments with colleagues.
Nevertheless, the findings reveal a meaningful gender difference in self-promotion, one that can contribute to disparities in recognition, compensation, and advancement—and to the gender pay gap.
Research on social backlash offers another clue. In three experiments, psychologist Laurie Rudman found that women who promoted their accomplishments received higher competence ratings but suffered social penalties, including reduced likability and lower hiring evaluations. These penalties varied with the evaluators' circumstances.
Other research found that anticipating negative reactions interfered with women's ability to promote themselves.
The conflict seems to be between deservedly wanting recognition and wanting to belong.
How Girls Learn That Expressing Pride Can Threaten Connection and Belonging
Imagine a girl who comes home delighted because she's received an "A" for her project on dinosaurs. She's eager to tell her parents, share her excitement, and celebrate with them.
But her parents are busy getting dinner ready. She's met with a distracted, "That's nice, honey. Now go set the table."
Or perhaps she receives the message that talking about her achievement makes her sister feel less important. She's expected to protect her sister's feelings rather than freely enjoy her own accomplishment.
Over time, she learns to keep her pride to herself rather than risk having her achievement undervalued and her sense of belonging diminished.
Also, Western social expectations still condition girls to be cooperative, accommodating, and attentive to others' feelings, and boys to compete, take pride in winning, and speak confidently about their achievements.
The bind is that girls are encouraged to achieve, but discouraged from expressing pride in these accomplishments.
Research on parental conditional regard helps explain how these expectations become internalized.
Psychologists Jolene Haines and Nicola Schutte conducted a meta-analysis involving 31 samples and 11,404 participants. They examined what happens when parents give or withdraw affection and approval depending on whether their children meet parental expectations.
The researchers found that conditional parental approval was associated with:
Self-worth dependent on approval: Children evaluated themselves according to whether they met others' expectations.
Greater pressure to comply: They felt compelled to behave in ways that secured approval or avoided guilt.
Weaker emotional connection: Conditional regard was associated with less closeness and belonging, along with more depressive symptoms.
Interestingly, giving extra affection when children behaved as expected was more strongly associated with internal pressure to comply than withdrawing affection when they disappointed their parents.
Both forms matter. Children learn which behaviors earn affection and which risk its withdrawal. As a result, preserving connection becomes more important than freely expressing themselves.
Although the study didn't specifically examine girls' accomplishments, it found that children whose parents tied affection to behavior felt more pressure to please others and based more of their self-worth on others' approval.
When Parents Have Difficulty Welcoming Their Child's Individuality
Parental influence can undermine a child's individuality—her thoughts, feelings, preferences, and sense of herself as a separate person.
Psychologist Brian Barber and colleagues interviewed 120 adolescents across five cultures about parental behaviors that made them feel disrespected as individuals. They then developed a measure administered to 2,100 adolescents.
Adolescents who experienced greater parental disrespect for their individuality reported more depression, anxiety, and problematic behavior. This measure of parental disrespect was more closely associated with these difficulties than a traditional measure of parental psychological control.
Why Children Become Selective About What They Share
Research on adolescent self-disclosure adds another dimension.
Alessio Vieno and Massimiliano Pastore studied 1,147 early adolescents and 959 parents, examining parental closeness, control, conflict, and adolescents' willingness to share information about themselves.
They found that parent-child closeness and parental control were related to adolescents' self-disclosure. Conflict was not significantly related in their reported model.
What children choose to share is connected to the relationships in which that sharing takes place.
Consider a girl whose excitement is warmly received by one parent but routinely dismissed by another. She has reason to share more openly with the parent who responds warmly and become guarded with the one who doesn't.
Although the researchers did not specifically examine disclosure of accomplishments, their findings establish an important connection between parenting relationships and what adolescents share.
Self-Silencing: When Protecting a Relationship Comes at the Cost of Professional Advancement
Psychologist Dana Crowley Jack described self-silencing as suppressing one's thoughts, feelings, or needs to preserve relationships and avoid conflict.
A meta-analysis by psychologists Sebastian Pintea and Andreea Gatea examined 42 studies involving 10,108 participants. They found a moderate association between self-silencing and depression: people who reported more self-silencing also tended to experience more depressive symptoms.
Researchers identified several aspects of self-silencing: evaluating yourself through others' judgments, sacrificing your own needs, suppressing feelings to avoid conflict, and presenting an agreeable outward self while privately experiencing different emotions.
That last pattern is particularly revealing. Someone can appear accommodating and comfortable while internally feeling disappointed, angry, or unseen.
Research connects self-silencing with poorer emotional well-being and relationship functioning. In the workplace, where recognition often influences promotions and compensation, consistently downplaying one's contributions also risks having good work overlooked.
When Your Body Remembers
Years later, you know you've done excellent work and deserve recognition. Yet when your manager asks you to describe your accomplishments, your chest tightens, your throat constricts, and anxiety rises.
You become self-conscious, searching for a modest response rather than enjoying the recognition you've earned.
Our nervous systems respond to perceived social threats, including criticism, rejection, and negative evaluation. Earlier relational experiences also shape the expectations we bring to similar situations in adulthood.
You can know that you're entitled to recognition and still feel uncomfortable talking openly about your accomplishments.
Changing the Pattern Means More Than Understanding It
Understanding how you learned to hold back can be liberating. But insight alone doesn't necessarily change an automatic emotional or bodily response.
In psychotherapy, we can explore and work to change what happens when you acknowledge an accomplishment aloud. Do you feel embarrassed? Does your body tighten? Do you immediately want to explain that other people helped?
Attachment-focused therapy helps us explore expectations about connection and acceptance formed in important relationships.
Parts-oriented approaches help us resolve the conflict between the part that wants recognition and the part that fears expressing pride will threaten belonging.
Somatic therapy helps us notice and gently work with the bodily responses accompanying these expectations. EMDR can help process earlier experiences and update beliefs that once made self-expression feel unsafe, supporting greater internal trust and freedom to acknowledge what you've done well.
These approaches address longstanding emotional and relational patterns, and hopefully support self-advocacy while maintaining a sense of belonging in the workplace.
Your recognition, opportunities for promotion, and paycheck may very well depend on it.
Women Shouldn't Have to Choose Between Recognition, Advancement, and Belonging
Not all discomfort with self-promotion originates in childhood. Environmental constraints are real. Women encounter real social penalties for asserting themselves or claiming credit. Women of color and transgender women especially face additional stereotypes and discrimination.
Organizations bear substantial responsibility for recognizing accomplishments fairly and creating workplaces where employees are encouraged to advocate for themselves without being socially penalized.
At the same time, women can examine whether old expectations about pleasing others and avoiding disapproval limit their freedom to express themselves.
You can appreciate your colleagues, care deeply about relationships, and still enjoy sharing your accomplishments, receiving recognition, and still be rewarded with opportunities for advancement.
Ready to Make a Change?
If you recognize yourself in these patterns, therapy might help you identify the root causes of your discomfort with sharing accomplishments you're proud of, or your tendency to downplay them.
I integrate evidence-based approaches, including somatic therapy, attachment-focused EMDR, and parts work, to help adults change longstanding patterns that no longer serve them.
I offer a free 20-minute consultation if you'd like to explore whether working together would be helpful.
Joanne Davis, LMFT | Online psychotherapy for adults throughout California
